Got lab stories? Every step is described and will let you know whether action is required. Rename .gz files according to names in separate txt-file. Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Read Editage Insights in your favorite RSS Reader. Academia Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education. Who is on the author list is not a deciding factor when evaluating a paper. Editorial contacts can be found by clicking on the "Help & support" button under the "For Authors" section of the journal's homepage as listed on SpringerLink. 2002 quality, format, scientific novelty, language etc). Peer review sometimes picks up fraud by chance, but generally it is not a reliable method for detecting fraud because it works on trust. The journal has confirmed that youve uploaded and submitted the correct documents and that the content of your paper is relevant to your journal. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Help us improve this article with your feedback. No, Modified on: Mon, 5 Sep, 2022 at 6:52 PM. What is the meaning of decision in process status? The Editor-in-Chief (EiC) makes the final decision on manuscript, with the associate editor (AE) making the initial decision. Share your stories! //--> "Editorial assessment of reviews" can mean that all reviewer send back their reviews and "Manuscript under editorial consideration" could mean that the editor hit the button "look at review". The chief editor is also involved in any recommendations for revision. Thanks for the response! The tabs offer authors the flexibility to navigate the submission form in any order and to return to incomplete sections where necessary. EB: Manuscript editors are completely unaware whether your paper has been given a waiver, or if you plan to publish gold open access, ensuring that the editorial assessment process remains completely independent. is still under consideration, You will also find this handbook useful:, Handbook: Keep Calm And Wait: A Guide To Understanding Journal Statuses. With Editor: The manuscript is under editorial consideration by one or more members of the Editorial Board who will When the status of your manuscript changes to under review, this means that it has passed the initial editorial checks. Any chance these are used in a bad or good way when describing a papers journey to being published? What does manuscript under editorial consideration mean? Now let it go and wait doing experiments and get use to rejection. Did you find it helpful? LS: I dont care who you are, or where youre from. Concepts & Synthesis articles present an evidence-supported opinion by established scientists on a research topic of ideally cross-disciplinary nature. Press ESC to cancel. rev2023.3.1.43269. ]]> this is editorial consideration. //-->Nature Neuroscience manuscript stage : r/labrats - reddit PACE helps ensure that figures meet PLOS requirements. What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? WebManuscript Submitted: The journal has received the submission and is screening it for basic technical requirements. [CDATA[> A paper may be rejected because of problems with the research on which it is based. That was kind of my take on it as well - if it was outright rejection it wouldn't need to go to an editorial consideration after editorial assessment of reviews. I submitted to Nature Neuroscience about 9 days ago and it's been "under consideration" for about a SR: Nature Physics is primarily a physics journal and as such looks for papers that focus on the underlying physics of a particular problem. The panel discussion was moderated by yours truly. Icons made by various authors from www.flaticon.com, Experiential Live Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts. Magdalena is a geneticist by training and has considerable editorial and publishing experience: having started in Nature Publishing Group in 2001, she was Chief Editor of Nature Reviews Genetics, Senior Editor for genetics and genomics at Nature, and more recently Executive Editor for the Nature Partner Journals. If it goes for review, then it will If you are interested in being a Guest Contributor, please contact us via email: thesource@springernature.com. Commun. This is more confusing as generally, 'Manuscript Under consideration' means that the editor is considering the manuscript for peer review. Editorial process is what separates content from simple data or information. Areas A guide to understanding journal statuses. [CDATA[> Alternatively, they may be considering that you submit to another journal within [CDATA[> [CDATA[> full consideration means we might consider rejecting it too. This is because you have been informed that your paper is under consideration for publication. Things just always take much longer than we think they would. All Rights Reserved. If you need any assistance please contact us at Author Support, or contact the responsible editor for the journal. Written by Marios Karouzos, Publishing Manager at Nature Portfolio. Here it should tell you if the articles are peer-reviewed. Editage.com.tw |Terms of UseforEnglish Editing Services. Time to First Decision: From submission to first decision, the journal aims to provide authors with a quick decision. Under Editorial Consideration - Check Status The manuscript below has entered the review process. It only takes a minute to sign up. Does this mean that they have already sent it out to the reviewers? Is variance swap long volatility of volatility? 2002 A Decision in Process soon after submission typically indicates that the manuscript is being desk-rejected. What does the typical workflow of a journal look like? I have a revised manuscript which I submitted to Nature Communications. So, the present status may mean that the EiC now needs to make a decision based on the peer review comments or on the revised manuscript. Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? The editorial process is iterative and highly subjective. Or reviewers are not responding to the editor after the request to review the revised manuscript by the editor? Cactus Communications. How do I write an inquiry to the editor about a delay in the decision on a revised manuscript? HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. //--> When your manuscript is accepted for publication, the corresponding author receives the proofs of your manuscript. You should hear back within a week or two. [CDATA[// > Home > Under Consideration vs. Under Editorial Consideration. Webmanuscript under editorial consideration nature methods. Guest Contributors include Springer Nature staff and authors, industry experts, society partners, and many others. MC: If you are worried about potential bias, all Nature Portfolio journals offer the option for a mutually anonymous peer review, where the identities of both the referees and the authors are hidden from each other throughout the peer-review process. For the status of your submission to Daniel Himmelstein of the University of California, San Francisco, analyzed submission and acceptance dates for all papers indexed in the PubMed database and found that the median time between submission and acceptance has been roughly 100 days for the past 30 years. EB: Like Nature Physics, Communication Physics is primarily a physics journal. Next steps for publishing your article: What to expect after acceptance, Timescale to publish an article for a Springer journal, Page numbers in a Continuous Article Publishing (CAP) Journal. This means that authors of an accepted paper can choose to pay an author publication charge to make their paper free in perpetuity under an open license (CC-BY) to maximise reuse. A manuscript under editorial consideration indicates that the work has not been rejected out of hand, but is being given a second look. WebThe editor is reading your manuscript and figuring out whether or not she wants to send it for peer review. WebThe manuscript was under review when it was showing 'all reviewers assigned' and when the status changed to 'under consideration' it means that reviews are back with her and Total length of the manuscript including figures and references . HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. The editor may confer with associate editors or reviewers for an evaluation to use in making this decision. Unless it is just rejected by an editor.So, OP, it is good. EB: Like Nature Physics, Communication Physics is primarily a physics journal. If the article is from an electronic journal, go to the journal home page and look for a link to About this journal or Notes for Authors. [CDATA[> How long does it take to publish a research paper? var d=new Date(); yr=d.getFullYear();document.write(yr); LS: Putting the original submitted version of a primary research paper on a preprint server has no impact whatsoever on the consideration of the paper in a Nature Portfolio journal. The manuscript was under review when it was showing 'all reviewers assigned' and when the status changed to 'under consideration' it means that reviews are back with her and she is discussing it with her collegues. PW: We read all the submissions we receive and assess them according to their content. Just want to clarify, that this question is specific to the editorial process of 'Nature Communications' which is not usual and not related to generalized peer review process. The EiC may have seen merits in your paper after all (or a fit, if that was the issue).